Console Wars Week 15

It looks pretty bad though.

It was the only one I had at the time.

It's almost impossible for me to pick between the 32X and PSX versions of Doom, I love them equally (albeit for different reasons) and they're my two favorite versions of Doom, I always rank them as split first place.

32X Doom:
+no load times
+instant level select
+enemies never walk away from you, they focus on you at all times
+enemies never ignore you because of friendly fire among themselves, they're smarter and more disciplined than that, hellbent on taking you down
+I am biased toward the sounds of the Mega Drive soundchip so it has my favorite renditions of the original Doom soundtrack
+perfect sound effects taken straight from the MS-DOS original
+overall good controls with instant weapon selection via combinations with the Mode button (6-button controller only)
+imo has the best version of the automap
+can be played through in one sitting, the perfect length for Doom imo
-no circle strafing, holding down the strafe button disables the ability to turn left and right until the strafe button is let go of
+brighter than any other version due to there not being any darkness shading for things in the distance, making it easier to see things that were too dark or even completely pitch black in other versions
-plays with a lower screen resolution than the PSX version, making some distant details harder to see than in the PSX version
-not played in proper fullscreen like the PSX version, making it additionally harder to see things in the distance than in the PSX version
-less colors on screen than the PSX version
-worse overall framerate than the PSX version and worse framedrops than the PSX version when the action picks up on the higher difficulties and there's a lot of action on screen
-lacking content like entire levels, the BFG9000 (which can still be accessed via a cheat code) and some items, enemies and bosses

Vs.

PSX Doom:
+great new graphics engine with vastly superior lighting effects than any other version
+updated high quality sound effects
+great new atmospheric soundtrack
+great controls with easy circle strafing
+has a save game feature
+the BFG9000 is available as a weapon without using cheat codes
+contains most of both Doom and Doom 2
+the additional content from Doom 2 is mixed in with the content from the original Doom to add more variety to an already great game
-no instant level select, if you haven't got a save file with the level you wanna play you'll have to play all the way until you get there again to play it
-no instant weapon selection, cycling through one weapon after another until you reach the one you want (at least as far as I recall there was no instant weapon selection in the PSX version, I could be remembering wrong though)
-rather long load times before levels
-enemies can walk away from you and ignore you, which is boring
-enemies fight among each other due to friendly fire among themselves, completely ignoring you in the process until they've killed each other off, which may be kind of practical but also really cheap and very boring
-it's too damn long, I find the original Doom too long already and this version mixes in Doom 2 as well, it's too much, it overstays it's welcome threefold at least, making it impossible (at least for me) to play through in one sitting

And everything else they pretty much both share equally.

The rest are known far and wide as some of the worst ports of Doom of all time, together with the Super Nintendo and Game Boy Advance ports.

I would go with the Saturn because their Quake was the most hyped. So having both games on the same system is more like an instant win. It is probably the weakest version of it though, but Doom at the time never thrived on consoles anyway.